![]() |
| Harry Shum Jr. — Photo: Gage Skidmore, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
There are bad nights on Dancing With the Stars, and then there is what happened to Harry Shum Jr. on Tuesday night.
The actor walked onto the ballroom floor for the Season 35 semifinals, danced twice, and did not put a foot wrong. The judges gave him a perfect 30 for his paso doble. Then another perfect 30 for his quickstep. Sixty out of sixty. Top of the leaderboard. And then, at the end of the episode, hosts Julianne Hough and Alfonso Ribeiro called his name anyway. Harry Shum Jr. and his professional partner Jenna Johnson were going home — one week before the finale.
If you watched it live, you probably stared at the screen, waited for someone to correct the mistake, and then went straight to your phone. You had heard it right. On Dancing With the Stars, a perfect score is not a guarantee. Sometimes it is not even close to enough.
A perfect night, until it wasn't
The semifinals asked everything of the six remaining couples. Each pair had to perform twice — one ballroom routine and one Latin dance — with a place in the finale on the line.
Harry and Jenna opened with a paso doble set to "We Found Love" by Rihanna and Calvin Harris. Three tens. A perfect 30. For their second dance, a quickstep to "Valerie," they did it again. Three more tens. Another perfect 30. That gave them 60 out of 60 for the night, the joint-highest score of the semifinals. Figure skater Amber Glenn and her partner Pasha Pashkov matched them — 30 for her salsa, 30 for her Viennese waltz. Nobody else came close.
It was also the third week in a row that Harry and Jenna had finished at the top of the leaderboard. All season long, they had looked like the couple to beat. Harry is not a celebrity who learned to dance for the show. He is a professional dancer who became an actor — the rare contestant who arrived in the ballroom with the hard part already mastered.
How the best dancer of the night went home
Here is the part that trips people up every season: the judges' scores are only half the result. On Dancing With the Stars, the leaderboard and the public vote each count for 50 percent. The judges can hand out all the tens they want, but if the viewers at home do not vote in big enough numbers, the couple with the lowest combined total is the one that leaves. The judges do not get the final say. The audience does.
![]() |
| Harry Shum Jr. at San Diego Comic-Con in 2017 — Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 |
TV Insider's breakdown of the result lays out why: with the scores worth half and the votes worth half, the only way a couple at the bottom survives over a couple at the top is by winning the viewer vote outright. The numbers point to Wood having pulled in the most viewer votes of all six celebrities on the night — enough to cancel out a 12-point gap and send the leaderboard-topper home instead. Whether that is the system working or the system failing depends on whose name you were voting for. But it is the system — and on Tuesday night it produced one of the most shocking eliminations the show has had in years.
The five who are left
With Harry and Jenna gone, five couples will dance in the Season 35 finale next Tuesday, November 24. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov sit at the top with their perfect 60. Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas follow on 59 (30 for their samba, 29 for their Viennese waltz). Paralympian Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach scored 57, including a perfect 30 for their jive. Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik are through on 55. And Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold — the lowest scorers of the night — are through on 48, carried by the viewers.
The finale airs Tuesday, November 24 at 8 p.m. ET as a three-hour live show on ABC and Disney+ — live across the whole country at the same time for the first time. Each couple will dance three routines: a judges' choice, an instant dance they learn on the night, and a freestyle. The winner takes home the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy. On paper, Amber Glenn now looks like the one to beat — but Tuesday night proved paper means very little here. If the lowest scorer can survive and the highest scorer can go home, then anyone in that final five can lift the trophy.
Who Harry Shum Jr. is — and why this one stung
For a lot of viewers, Harry was no ordinary contestant. Most people first met him as Mike Chang, the quiet dancer of McKinley High on Glee, a role he played for all six seasons from 2009 to 2015. Then came Magnus Bane, the flamboyant warlock of Shadowhunters, a part that turned him into a fan-favorite leading man. These days he plays Dr. Benson Kwan on Grey's Anatomy, and he has been on the big screen in Crazy Rich Asians and Everything Everywhere All at Once.
But before any of that, he was a dancer. Born in Costa Rica and raised in California, Harry danced on tour with Beyoncé and performed with Jennifer Lopez and Mariah Carey before his acting career took off. When the season 35 cast was announced and he was paired with pro Jenna Johnson — herself a former Mirrorball champion — it felt like the show had finally given its best dancer a real shot at the trophy. That is why Tuesday hurt. It was not just that a good dancer lost. It was that a dancer who had spent the whole season at the top, who had done everything the judges asked perfectly, lost to a system that decided the judges were only half the story.
What Harry said next
Harry did not wait long to speak to the fans who had carried him through the season. After the elimination, he posted a Reel on Instagram thanking them and telling them how "proud" he felt — and he dropped a hint that this might not be the last anyone sees of him and Jenna on the dance floor. Eliminated couples traditionally return for the finale, so expect to see him back in the ballroom on November 24.
![]() |
| Harry Shum Jr. at a public appearance — Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 |


