Netflix has a new number one movie, and it comes with an argument attached. Heartland, the country-music thriller starring Jessica Chastain, debuted at the top of Netflix's English-language film list with 7.3 million views in its first three days — and almost nobody can agree on whether it is actually good.
The film landed on Netflix on Friday, November 13, and topped the chart for the week of November 9–15. It beat holiday competitor A Dog's Perfect Christmas (7.2 million views) and Tyler Perry's The Gospel of Christmas (6.1 million) by the narrowest of margins. What's on Netflix called the 7.3 million figure a soft opening for a major star-led Friday release — but a number one is a number one, and in the streaming era, the chart is the box office. Millions of people pressed play. The question is what they thought when the credits rolled.
Jessica Chastain at the Berlin International Film Festival in February 2025. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
A missing niece, a comeback, and a Nashville mystery
Chastain plays Misty Jones, a former country music legend who walked away from the spotlight twenty years ago and now lives a quiet, secluded life on a pecan farm in Georgia. Then her brother Donny calls with terrible news: his daughter Charlie Heart, played by Carter Faith, an up-and-coming country star, has gone missing in Nashville. Misty sets out to find her niece, and the search drags her back into the world she left behind for good.
The cast around her is built to support it. Garrett Hedlund plays record label boss Roy Combs, Ross Lynch is Jace, Charlie's boyfriend, Jennifer Nettles is Misty's nemesis Winnie Jo Lean, and John Hawkes is her former husband Clark. The film runs one hour and fifty-two minutes, written and directed by Shana Feste, who made the country-music drama Country Strong back in 2010.
Feste has said Misty is an amalgam of the women who shaped country music: a little Emmylou Harris, Tanya Tucker, Marshall Chapman, Loretta Lynn, and Miranda Lambert. Feste told Decider she loves how female country singers have always been a little bit irreverent and outspoken. Misty is all of that, with twenty years of silence on top.
The film itself refuses to sit still in one genre. Chastain put it best when she spoke to Netflix's Tudum: "Every time I thought I understood what kind of film it was, it completely changed lanes." That restlessness is either the movie's greatest strength or its biggest problem, depending on who you ask.
Nashville at night — the city where Heartland's mystery unfolds. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.
The numbers say hit. The reviews say it's complicated
Here is where the story gets interesting. Heartland holds a 61 percent critics' score on Rotten Tomatoes, alongside a 40 percent audience score as of November 17. IMDb users have it at 5.6 out of 10. On Letterboxd, where the film crowd keeps score, it sits at 2.6 out of 5.
Together they paint a picture: critics mildly warm, audiences considerably colder, nobody raving. The thriller twists land for some and not for others, and the shifts between family drama, music movie, and mystery keep some viewers leaning in while others wonder what kind of film they are watching. It is the classic streaming paradox: a film can top the chart and divide the room at the same time.
The one thing everyone agrees on
Strip away the arguments about plot, pacing, and tone, and there is exactly one thing the reviews agree on: Jessica Chastain herself.
Letterboxd reviewers who were unimpressed by almost everything else still stopped to praise her. "Jessica Chastain is unsurprisingly top notch," one wrote. Another was blunter: "She carries this thing on HER BACK." Rotten Tomatoes audience reviewers used the same language, calling her "great" and an "exceptional actor."
That is the pattern of her whole career. Chastain commits completely, even when the material around her wobbles. She won the Academy Award for The Eyes of Tammy Faye, a Golden Globe for Zero Dark Thirty, and earned Oscar nominations for The Help and Zero Dark Thirty. She is the rare movie star whose presence alone makes a film worth arguing about, and Heartland is the latest proof.
Yes, that's really her singing — and she was terrified
There is one more twist, and it might be the best part: that really is Jessica Chastain singing in Heartland. And she did not want to do it.
After playing Tammy Wynette in the Showtime series George & Tammy in 2022, she told everyone around her she would never sing on screen again. "I will never do that again," she said. Then the Heartland script arrived. "No way, I'm not doing it," was her first reaction. And then she read it. "It was just too good to pass up."
Director Shana Feste told Decider it took some convincing. "She was definitely a little shy when we first got into the studio," Feste said. Chastain herself told Entertainment Weekly it was nerve-wracking. "Singing is not my great love or passion, but I like to tell a story through song," she said. "We had a class in my college [Juilliard], and the great teacher Deb Lapidus, who taught us how a song could be a monologue."
It fits the character: Misty spent twenty years dimming her light, trying to disappear and not feel anything, and singing makes her feel things again. Chastain performs several songs in the film, including a duet with Jennifer Nettles, and "Still the Sparrow Sings," written by her young co-star Carter Faith. She practiced the songs and piano before filming in Nashville and Atlanta.
Asked by People whether this means more singing roles are coming, Chastain had a short answer: "I'm done." For now, at least, Misty Jones is the last singer she plays.
Next stop: Broadway
Chastain is not slowing down. On November 11, it was announced that she will return to Broadway in the spring in a new play called Lost Lear, written and directed by Irish theatermaker Dan Colley. Performances begin March 29, 2027, at the Booth Theatre, with opening night set for April 23, and the run lasts sixteen weeks. Corey Stoll and Michael Urie co-star.
She plays Joy, a former actress living with dementia who believes she is rehearsing Shakespeare's King Lear. It is a long way from a Nashville thriller — and that is the point. Chastain, a two-time Tony nominee, has built her career on these swings: a demonic matriarch in the horror film Other Mommy, which reached cinemas in October, a country singer in Heartland, and now a woman losing herself inside the greatest role in theatre.
The Booth Theatre on Broadway, where Chastain returns in Lost Lear in spring 2027. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.
A number one people argue about is still a number one
So what do we make of Heartland? The chart says hit, the reviews say flawed, the audience says Chastain is magnificent either way. In the streaming era, that might be the best possible outcome: a film people watch, argue about, and keep talking about.
That is what a movie star does: she gives people something to fight over. And right now the fight is happening on Netflix's number one movie, with Jessica Chastain carrying the whole thing on her back — singing included.
Heartland is streaming now on Netflix.


